Skip to content
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • About CRB
    • Governing Body
    • Team
    • Code of Conduct
    • Achievements & Affiliations
    • Annual Reports
    • Financials & Legal Documents
  • What We Do
    • Operational Verticals
    • Industry Sector
      • Agro Based Industries
      • Apparel And Textiles
      • ICT And Electronics
      • Mining and Minerals
    • Thematic Areas
      • Circular Economy
      • Business & Human Rights
      • Private Sector & SDGs
      • SMEs & Sustainability
      • Voluntary Sustainability Standards
      • Environment & Climate Change
  • Current Initiatives
    • Youth Engagement on Sustainability (YES)
      • Youth for Sustainability (YfS) India Alliance
      • Engagement & Representations
      • Youth for Sustainable Palm Oil Fellowship
    • Nutrition Security in India
      • Nutrition Innovation Mini-Challenge
    • PROGRESS (Global Value Chains & SDGs)
    • VSS Collaboration India
    • India Sustainability Standards (ISS)
    • Sustainable Palm Oil
      • Sustainable Palm Oil Coalition
      • Sustainability Ambassador
    • Sustainable Agro Value Chains
      • TEEB Agri Food
      • FOLU India CREST
    • Mapping and Conceptualizing Of EU–CSR & Sustainability Action Platform in India
    • Circular Electronics
    • Self-Assessment Framework on Business & Human Rights for Indian Apparel & Textile Industry
  • Knowledge Hub
    • Blog
    • News Room
    • Publications
    • Events & Updates
  • Careers
Menu
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • About CRB
    • Governing Body
    • Team
    • Code of Conduct
    • Achievements & Affiliations
    • Annual Reports
    • Financials & Legal Documents
  • What We Do
    • Operational Verticals
    • Industry Sector
      • Agro Based Industries
      • Apparel And Textiles
      • ICT And Electronics
      • Mining and Minerals
    • Thematic Areas
      • Circular Economy
      • Business & Human Rights
      • Private Sector & SDGs
      • SMEs & Sustainability
      • Voluntary Sustainability Standards
      • Environment & Climate Change
  • Current Initiatives
    • Youth Engagement on Sustainability (YES)
      • Youth for Sustainability (YfS) India Alliance
      • Engagement & Representations
      • Youth for Sustainable Palm Oil Fellowship
    • Nutrition Security in India
      • Nutrition Innovation Mini-Challenge
    • PROGRESS (Global Value Chains & SDGs)
    • VSS Collaboration India
    • India Sustainability Standards (ISS)
    • Sustainable Palm Oil
      • Sustainable Palm Oil Coalition
      • Sustainability Ambassador
    • Sustainable Agro Value Chains
      • TEEB Agri Food
      • FOLU India CREST
    • Mapping and Conceptualizing Of EU–CSR & Sustainability Action Platform in India
    • Circular Electronics
    • Self-Assessment Framework on Business & Human Rights for Indian Apparel & Textile Industry
  • Knowledge Hub
    • Blog
    • News Room
    • Publications
    • Events & Updates
  • Careers

Measuring the S of ESG in the Apparel Industry

  • May 9, 2022

share this

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Dr. Ashima Mathur

Dr. Ashima Mathur

Project Officer, CRB
Linkedin

Studies have suggested that environmental, social, and governance factors impact business performance, and there is a growing interest of stakeholders to integrate ESG factors into business[1]. Businesses need to focus not only on mitigating risk but also on contributing towards the global environmental goals, act socially responsible and become more inclusive and diverse.

The apparel industry is complex and fragmented with long supply chains that are often opaque as we reach the last tier. This nature of supply chains can often lead to concerns around the behaviour and contribution of manufacturers and suppliers, towards environment, employees, and community.   The increasing scrutiny of stakeholders of environmental and social concerns not only causes serious reputational damage to business but oftentimes a supplier may lose their business when a leading retailer or brand discovers that a supplier is not living up to their values and expectations. In other words, issues such as human rights violations, environmental ruthlessness or other ethical infringements have the potential to have a negative impact on business as the company’s actions are increasingly influencing stakeholders and their interactions with shareholders and their demands[2].

The environmental issues have received a lot of attention, and the governance issues are covered by laws under which the businesses are already operating. Businesses are often left with the question of what the ‘S’ of ESG entails for them as well as how it can be implemented and measured. The social dimension covers issues on human rights, labour, health and safety, working conditions, employee benefits, diversity and inclusion, consumers and community at large[3].

Incidents at Rana Plaza and other similar instances have highlighted the importance of the social dimension for the apparel industry. Though after the Rana Plaza incident the apparel businesses are actively integrating ESG issues in the business strategy, the industry is still plagued with many labour and human rights issues. To name some, health and safety issues, lack of adequate sanitation facilities, gender pay gaps, abuse and harassment, no social security benefits, frequent over time, low or no employment of women at supervisory or managerial roles, wage rate below living wages, no formal employment contracts are often observed in the industry. 

All these issues can clearly be categorized under different heads of ‘S’ as mentioned above. The reason for the existence of social issues in the apparel supply chain can be attributed to the long supply chains as it is difficult to capture these issues till the very last mile. It is also important to highlight that suppliers often find themselves in the crossroads of maintaining price pressures and sustainability pressures. 

In the myriad of challenges faced by businesses, integrating social issues seems like a puzzle with many pieces. Identifying key material issues, implementation and measuring impact requires technical knowledge, financial cost and time. In addition to this, the indicators for social issues are difficult to quantify[4]. In an attempt to resolve these issues and increase the adoption of social sustainability, many voluntary standards and frameworks have been developed. However, these tools being developed in the global North, are not able to capture the cultural and management context of South Asian countries, leading to compliance being just a tick box exercise.  

The solution to these challenges requires a deeper understanding of the sustainability issues and developing multi stakeholder partnerships. There is a need to involve the relevant stakeholders in not only project implementation but also in policy development. To conclude, sustainability is for the people- the shareholders and the stakeholders and no goal can be achieved without involving the people.

[1] https://hbr.org/2021/01/esg-impact-is-hard-to-measure-but-its-not-impossible

[2] https://sdwatch.eu/2020/02/environmental-and-social-impacts-of-fast-fashion/

[3] https://www.spglobal.com/en/research-insights/articles/what-is-the-s-in-esg

[4] https://ssir.org/articles/entry/fixing_the_s_in_esg

 

Five Future Trends For Responsible Business in India

National Small Industry Day : “Every Big scale endeavor always starts from Small” 30th August 2022

Industrial Sustainability with renewable energy

International Youth Day: History and Relevance

Building Back Better – A More Resilient and Equitable System for People and Nature.

A supply side Commentary on the Agriculture sector in the current climate

Partners so far

1
2
3
4
5
logo
logo1
logo2
logo3
logo4
logo5
logo6
logo7
logo8
logo9
logo10
logo11
logo12
logo13
logo14
logo15
logo16
logo17
logo18
logo19
logo20
logo21
logo22
logo23
logo24
logo25
logo26
logo27
logo29
logo30
logo31
logo32
logo33
logo34
logo35
logo36
logo37
logo38
logo39
logo40
logo41
logo42
logo43
logo44
logo45
logo46
logo47
logo48
logo49
logo50
awslogonew
logo52
logo53
logo54
logo55
logo56
logo57
logo58
logo59
logo60
logo61
logo62
logo63
logo64
logo65
logo66
logo67
logo68
logo69
logo70
logo71
logo72
logo73
logo74
logo75
logo76
logo77
logo78
logo79
logo80
logo81
logo82
logo83
logo84
logo85
logo86
logo87
logo88
logo89
logo90
logo91
logo92
logo93
logo94
logo95
Previous
Next

Get In Touch

CENTRE FOR RESPONSIBLE BUSINESS

USO House, USO Road, 6 Special Institutional Area, Off Shaheed Jeet Singh Marg,New Delhi-110067 (India)

+91 9582994251

info@c4rb.org

Facebook
Twitter
Youtube
Linkedin
Instagram

Important Links

Home

About CRB

News

Blogs

Legal Documents

Contact Us

Privacy Policy

CRB on Twitter

Tweets by Centre4RespBiz
Facebook
Twitter
Youtube
Linkedin
Instagram